Atma Xplorer

Xploring Games, Computing, Photography

Real or Fake? Debunking the Sony Memory Stick

For most new PSP users, it’s always a dilemma when choosing what Memory Stick to buy. No, it’s not about capacity since 2GB and 4GB are the most bought capacities. It’s rather a choice between Original Memory Sticks and Class A (Fake ones) Memory Sticks. Now, both products work as advertised but they have their own advantages, To help you decide, here’s some reference on the difference between the two:

Price over Quality

Class A Memory Sticks are dirt cheap. If you know where to look, you can find capacities that cost less than half of original ones. While this is certain to sway most into buying cheap, take not that Class A memory sticks lasts shorter compared to original ones. This is due to several factors like materials used, production process, cost cutting etc. Original Sticks come with a good length of warranty too so if something happens, you can get it replaced, no questions asked.

Advantage: Depends on what you’re looking for, price or quality?

Storage Capacity

Due to a difference in production, Fake Memory Sticks carry a different capacities from the originals. Class A 2GB Memory sticks have 1948MB and 1959MB of storage space while Genuine ones have just 1909MB or 1910MB.

Advantage: Class A

Access Speed

Again due to production differences, Original Memory Sticks have a transfer rate of 80Mbps while Class A memory Sticks get about 60Mbps to 70Mbps. It make not look much of a difference but it’s quite noticeable in terms of gameplay. How? If you have a game saved on your memory stick (say, CFW and a PSP game download) and it’s in cso (a compressed ISO), you’ll notice that the game loads a lot faster in an Original Memory Stick than a Class A one.

Advantage: Original

Physical Structures

Some Class A Memory Sticks are thicker than Originals. If you try and force them into an adapter, you might damage the adapter, the memory stick, or both. There’s also been some cases of Class A Memory Sticks not fitting into a PSP.

Advantage: Original

Miscellaneous

Seals
Original Sony Package Seals have long staple like seals which makes them very hard to open without damaging the package. This is to ensure that buyers will get their Memory Sticks fresh from the seal. Class A Memory Sticks however sealed up using glue so they’re easy to rip open.

Label
The words on an Original Memory Stick is carved on it’s back. Class A Memory sticks have them printed. To check whether you have an original card, just feel the letters, if they’re engraved, you’ve got an original stick.

Photos:
Here’s some photos for comparison:

Original Memory Stick
Original Memory Stick

FAKE or Class A
Class A or Fake Memory Stick

In Conclusion

If you’re going to have just ONE Memory Stick for storage, I suggest you go with an Original Sony Memory Stick. It out-performs, last-longer, and has more value (warranty) than Class A ones. If absolutely need a spare card, get a Class A Memory Stick. Now if you really can’t afford an original, there’s not much you can do about it but to put off buying one until you can right?

Tags: , ,

Comments ( 3 )

Have Something To Say ?

  1. PIC Microcontroller April 5, 2008 Reply

    medyo ok naman sa akin ang class-A memory sticks

  2. sylv3rblade April 6, 2008 Reply

    [re=1520]PIC Microcontroller[/re]: well there’s really nothing wrong with using Class A memory Sticks (aside from stealing revenue from the official makers ) but I think with our precious save games on the line, it’s better to be safe than sorry ^^

  3. kathy_rollo February 20, 2010 Reply

    sylv3rblade, what Pro Duo brand do you prefer? Officially, I’ve read there are currently 3 manufacturers for the Pro Duo format:

    SONY
    SanDisk
    Lexar

    With the sticks being ORIGINAL held as a constant variable, can you write a blog entry comparing the 3 brands by performance (read/write speed), quality, material, and price?

    I never really got an objective answer for this.

Leave a Reply

website stats